I once heard that Neal A. Maxwell (and this could totally be hearsay) was asked to conduct a survey to determine why Latter-day Saints seem to have difficult time with the old phenomenon of "keeping up with the Joneses [He apologized that the Jones name was sullied by the implication of envy - and noted that next to "Smith" it was most common name in phone book, but that it had recently been passed up by Johnson].
He found that this phenomenon is stimulated in part, by the fact that Latter-day Saints meet together more frequently and visit through HT/VT in homes; It becomes a natural thing to see who has what new things to want to keep up with; members of other churches generally meet less frequently so they dont seem to have the problem to the same degree as Mormons.
So how can we counteract the phenomenon?
Teach doctrine. (Any other suggestions?)
Pres. Hinckley has said that the forumula of "Buy now, pay later = catastrophe"... that credit card debt is financial suicide... yet we find so many members who fall into the trap of keeping up with the Johnson's.
Any ideas to help combat this other than doing your VT/HT by phone?
__________________
no unhallowed hand can stop the work from progressing... the truth of God will go forth till it has penetrated every website, sounded in every ear, till the purposes of God shall be accomplished and the great Jehovah shall say the work is done
The Lord's plan has always been "faith precedes the miracle." For the blessings of the temple, one must demonstrate a consistent effort of living the laws of the Gospel.
Satan's plan is (and has always been) "get what you want now and pay later." And it galls me that for my house and my education, I followed that plan, even if they can be redefined as "investments." I'll rejoice when they are finally paid off.
I think sincere gratitude is a sure cure for "keeping up with the Johnsons," which can be more simply defined as coveting. When I started really thanking God for the blessings I have, I stopped caring about what everyone else has. And I became more generous with my friends and neighbors.
Who wants to keep up with the Johnsons anyway? It's just more "stuff" to try to protect, maintain and keep organized. The past few years, Sister Roper and I have been simplifying our lives. We've given a lot of "stuff" to the Johnsons.
__________________
The ability to qualify for, receive, and act on personal revelation is the single most important skill that can be acquired in this life. - Julie Beck
MrCoco and I were just talking about how little was said concerning money at this last Gen. Conf. I know, there was probably something said, so you don't need to go link me to everything. We were just commenting on how money and infidelity are the two big causes of divorce. I don't think the Church has any better record for divorces than the pop. at large. I know it's hard to calculate temple divorces because many people are divorced who haven't bothered to cancel the temple sealing, so "on paper" they're still temple married. But anyway-- money is a huge problem in the Church and without. I'm not sure quite what to think or how I'd go about changing it. You can preach till you're blue in the face but if people don't want to hear... It's their desires- the things of the world- so, what can you do?
__________________
Life is tough but it's tougher if you're stupid. -John Wayne
Simple way to stop keeping up with the Jones / Johnsons...
Make everyone in your ward who has that surname change it, and if they are not willing to change their name to a non-Jones or non-Johnson name, then cast them out from amongst you... Problem solved. No more Joneses or Johnsons, no one to try to keep up with anymore.
__________________
It seems to me the only thing you've learned is that Caesar is a "salad dressing dude."
It is a rare thing not to compare oneself to another. It is a basic way that the human brain learns. By comparing differences we learn what is proper and improper--in a way it's how we learn to stop from making mistakes without experimentation.
If you see someone else doing something, you can mimick it...
In the process, we must learn which things are worthy of emulation and which things are not. In the church, we admire a lot of folk, often we interract with an assortment of people from different ages and with different points of view. We share our testimony each week, and strengthen each other with the Spirit through the words we say, the actions we choose, the donations we give, and the love we share.
And as we all strive to understand and learn and be better, it's only natural that our imperfect role-models rub off on us...
Now, if you think it's bad in the church... just imagine a world without any decent rolemodels... A whole means of learning is taken from many people in this world, which breeds contempt, cynicism, mocking, derision, hatred and loathing of one's fellow man...
So I'll stick with the prior and put up with a little Jonesism...
--Ray
__________________
I'm not slow; I'm special. (Don't take it personally, everyone finds me offensive. Yet somehow I manage to live with myself.)
I think part of the problem is that some members equate riches with being righteous. Also, I do see a problem with a society as a whole of various denomonations of young people thinking that they need to have what their parents or grandparents worked years to achieve right from the start.
I can't think of one member of my ward or stake that has something that I want also. Well there is that family I hometeach where the husband has a motorcycle but I've been placed under a strict order from my wife that I cannot have one until the last child turns 18.
What is it that people are trying to keep up with. A nicer house? A more expensive car? More toys?
Didn't Brother Brigham say that prosperity would be one of our greatest trials to overcome?
__________________
no unhallowed hand can stop the work from progressing... the truth of God will go forth till it has penetrated every website, sounded in every ear, till the purposes of God shall be accomplished and the great Jehovah shall say the work is done
I was thinking about how basic it is to compare ourselves with another, to emulate each other and how we learn. So often we want to be just like others we see, sure, but then I got to thinking that so often we want to be different from others for all the wrong reasons as well.
This whole life and learning thing... it's pretty natural to make lots of mistakes at it. Basic human tendencies aside, however, I'm grateful to have a conscience to help distinguish whether I am on one extreme or another.
I guess that's an attribute we should seek to develop.
--Ray
__________________
I'm not slow; I'm special. (Don't take it personally, everyone finds me offensive. Yet somehow I manage to live with myself.)
I think many people base their feeling of self worth not on how they compare to their own potential, but on how they compare to someone else's perceived progress.
__________________
If ye love wealth better than liberty, the tranquility of servitude than the animated contest of freedom, go from us in peace. May your chains sit lightly upon you, and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen! - Samuel Adams
Great point, arbi. And that's the whole basis of sins like greed, coveting, envy...isn't it?
Your $250k home is great if you're surrounded by people whose homes are only $150k. Your $250k home sucks if you're surrounded by people with multi-million dollar homes.
In high school you were pretty dang smart because you were valedictorian, #1. At the university you realize you really don't know jack squat.
__________________
Life is tough but it's tougher if you're stupid. -John Wayne
no unhallowed hand can stop the work from progressing... the truth of God will go forth till it has penetrated every website, sounded in every ear, till the purposes of God shall be accomplished and the great Jehovah shall say the work is done
In high school you were pretty dang smart because you were valedictorian, #1. At the university you realize you really don't know jack squat.
I had the opposite experience. Was pretty average in highschool and got into business school in college and was at or towards the top of the pile. Couldn't believe how stupid some of those folks were. Deans list, presidents lists, Magna Cum Laude, and friends with the top students in the Business School. Then I got into graduate school and found everyone else was one of the top dogs and I was just average again. That really stank!!!!
I do find myself sometimes comparing my sprituality to this brother or that brother in the ward or my family who won't stop wiggling in Sacrament to the perfect families whose perfectly groomed angels are sitting quietly and paying attention. Fortunately, I have enough common sense to immediately snap out of my envy and remind myself that those same folks also have their struggles and problems, many of which they hide well or we don't see. The family whose house is so immaculate that you can eat of the floor isn't to be envied because the house is that immaculate because the wife suffers from OCD and obsesses about every single piece of dirt and clutter to the point of depression. The brother who seems like a spiritual giant may be having marriage problems or anger issues at home with his kids. We each have our own set of blessings and burdens tailor made for our own progression. Worrying about how our kids aren't as perfect as the Jones family or not as good a students as the Johnson family is counterproductive.
So... seeing that it's counterproductive, which I agree with... how do we counteract this? (To get back to the original question...) Remind ourselves that somehow Person A's life sucks, too? Even though we don't see it?
__________________
Life is tough but it's tougher if you're stupid. -John Wayne
I think you should think of all your fellow saints as huge hypocrites who are hiding a butt-load of sins and that any moment their facade is going to crack and they're gonna go postal... That's a very comforting thought, cuz in that situation, I'm soooooo much better than them! ;)
--Ray
__________________
I'm not slow; I'm special. (Don't take it personally, everyone finds me offensive. Yet somehow I manage to live with myself.)
When I compare myself to others, I get depressed. Sometimes we need to remember that the only way people get good at something is by working hard for it, so instead of trying to become someone else, I've been focused on becoming Myself...and not just myself, but my BEST self. There are some goals that I have been working toward for years that I haven't come close to reaching yet (I'll never be immaculate), but as long as I'm working on them, the stuff that other people have, and the traits and the qualities, don't matter as much any more. I'm kind of glad I don't have all the money I need to live that "fabulous" life, because somehow, making life fabulous by other means works so much better. Does it really get any better than having someone make you grilled cheese and tomato soup for lunch?
__________________
Ordinary riches can be stolen, real riches cannot. In your soul are infinitely precious things that cannot be taken from you.
— Oscar Wilde
I once overheard a member telling another member that I couldn't be that good as a dentist because I only drove a Towncar. (They had no clue I was listening and couldn't see me) All of her dentists drove better cars than that!
I told my wife the story and a couple of weeks later... wha la... she had me driving a Beemer.
I'm ready to sell it and get a nice Hyundai Sonata or something. Beemrs are really expensive as far as upkeep goes....etc... I do enjoy all of the little luxuries, but I'd be just as happy in a Ford pickup.
Yes, there are those that I emulate and try to be more like spiritually. Our two patriarchs come to mind... (and I ordained one of them as a patriarch.... that was one of the most spiritual experiences of my life.)
__________________
no unhallowed hand can stop the work from progressing... the truth of God will go forth till it has penetrated every website, sounded in every ear, till the purposes of God shall be accomplished and the great Jehovah shall say the work is done
Your wife got you a Beemer because some woman said something negative about a Lincoln?? Wow. Guess that'd be easy to manipulate... when you're sick of the BMW, that is. Have her "overhear" how BMW's are yuck and for weenies and Ford trucks are actually the new status symbol if you have any measure of testosterone at all. The more gas-guzzling the better. Plus, how can you pull the 30' skiboat with some Beemer? Joke.
__________________
Life is tough but it's tougher if you're stupid. -John Wayne
Never been attracted to cars, I just like it when they run and don't break or cost me lots of time and extra money. Sometimes though when I see the "external" priorities of my fellow saints, I wonder to myself if I have some kind of selfish and unhealthy preoccupation on church stuff, rather than the acquisition of nicer newer stuff or simply to do a better job at home repair... Mow the Lawn or go help my hometeaching family mow the lawn, I'll neglect mine anyday... In fact my second daughter and I have a secret pact that we don't want any of the neighbors to know... We secretly love Dandelions.
--Ray
__________________
I'm not slow; I'm special. (Don't take it personally, everyone finds me offensive. Yet somehow I manage to live with myself.)
My brother-in-law and I went through the same MBA program, but were a year apart in MBA class. He focused in Finance, I in HRM and MIS. Anyway, when we talk about corporate America, he likes to remind me of one of the fiscal maxims we learned in the basic finance class all candidates of the program took -- if you want to determine how wise a company is with their money, look to see how frequently they are sponsoring sporting venues or events.
Anyone care to venture a guess as to what it means?
The moral is that if they are wasting money on buying the naming rights to this or that stadium or this or that football bowl game or this or that PGA tournament or fancy schmancy multi-million dollar ad campaigns, you have to ask the question where else are the exectives of the firm wasting the corporation's money and squandering the shareholder's earnings.
Now, translate that down into the smaller business viewpoint. Buying the trappings of looking like you are well to do as a Dentist or Doctor or small business owner / manager does not make you successful. In fact, it will more times than not end up driving you out of a competitive advantage or environment. Why? Furnishings / trappings / nice things do not have a thing to do with the business' core competency... or in other words what it is the business does well and justifies its being in the marketplace. It increases overhead and cost. That overhead and cost gets passed on to the business' consumers in the form of higher costs. Higher costs make consumers go elsewhere. Less consumers, less revenue. Less revenue, same fixed costs (which include the sunk and incremental costs on the "nice things"), less profit. Less profit = short term, less successful than the competition, long term inability to grow the business in meaningful ways that contribute to future success of the business.
I have a lot more respect for a businessperson who lives like a normal person than living the high life just because they are in a "position" that seems to require it and because they make >=2x or 3x or 4x or more my salary in a bad economic cycle year than me.
So, next time the wife insists you drive a Beemer so those who are defining what keeping up with the Jones is are happy, give her a lesson in macro economics! Oh, and send the Beemer my way, informing her that though you won't be driving it, the expense will be going for a more worthy cause!
__________________
It seems to me the only thing you've learned is that Caesar is a "salad dressing dude."
Amazingly I had a number of my patients who said, "I'm so glad I can tell my friends that my dentist drives a Beemer.... it just didn't sound like you were good enough when you drove a Towncar.
On the other hand, there are a group of patients that now are starting to think I charge too much.
(I charge less than most but am just below average for AZ)
You can't win them all.
Sad isn't it?
I'm ready for an F-250 super cab.
And truth be told... we went shopping together and when we drove the one we bought we both fell in love. It took me almost two weeks to talk them down to the price I wanted to pay but eventually they caved.
-- Edited by Mahonri at 18:09, 2007-04-24
__________________
no unhallowed hand can stop the work from progressing... the truth of God will go forth till it has penetrated every website, sounded in every ear, till the purposes of God shall be accomplished and the great Jehovah shall say the work is done
I found it ... (some benign word right here that I can't quite put my finger on)... that you would, instead of explaining to your dear wife the folly of this silly woman's ways, you go ahead and get the dang Beemer! Hello!
With all due respect, of course...
And you don't need to "be careful" of me. Although MrCoco seems to think I have a knack for scheming.
Disclaimer- what I feel is due respect is entirely up to me.
__________________
Life is tough but it's tougher if you're stupid. -John Wayne
But, with all due respect, when the phrase is used, others may not know what you feel is due respect, particularly if respect is due and the amount has not been laid out in a straight forward manner...
So, when all due respect has been paid, it may actually end up that a credit or debit balance of respect may be due. And if it means there is still an upaid respect balance, then all due respect has not been given...
Which makes me wonder, when someone has paid you more respect than is due, do you return the superfluous amount of respect that has been overpaid? Or like some medical professional's offices we have dealt with, does the duplicate payment of a patient's co-pay conveniently get overlooked with a "overpayment, what do you mean?" and booked as "free cash" to apply towards non-paying patients or insurance disallowances?
__________________
It seems to me the only thing you've learned is that Caesar is a "salad dressing dude."
You make the fatal assumption that it's even possible to pay more respect than is due. At least while I play creditor. While I'm debtor, well, that's another story. And if the respect was superfluous to begin with, yes it will be returned. With honor.
__________________
Life is tough but it's tougher if you're stupid. -John Wayne
Mahonri wrote:Didn't Brother Brigham say that prosperity would be one of our greatest trials to overcome?
Obviously Heavenly Father knows that I cannot handle prosperity, He has saved me from that trial, I am GRATEFUL... I don't mind being as poor as a church mouse because my children walk in faith and my hubby is faithful and loving to me. We live simply and I only wish I had better health... but mostly that is so I could enjoy all the blessings of my wonderful family more fully and for longer here in this life. I have "enough and to spare" so that I can give to others as I feel impressed to do. My health costs are not a burden on others, but it takes most of our income over needs to meet those expenses... Hubby has never once made me feel that he is sorry he married me...
Since this life IS the test I am praying for the eternities to make up for what we lack here...but those blessings I pray for are not "things" either.
Seriously, I'd like to hear from Mahonri, since he brought the subject up. It seems with your wife's prompting, you are not just keeping up with the Jones' but with the Jones' THOUGHTS on the matter. ??
__________________
Life is tough but it's tougher if you're stupid. -John Wayne